Search This Blog

Showing posts with label election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label election. Show all posts

Saturday, September 8, 2012

PBS Newshour Sep 7 2012


Check out the areas I have highlighted

ANALYSIS    AIR DATE: Sept. 7, 2012

Shields and Brooks Wrap on 2012 Democratic National Convention

SUMMARY

Syndicated columnist Mark Shields and New York Times columnist David Brooks talk to Judy Woodruff about the dreary August jobs report, how undecided voters may have perceived the Democratic National Convention and whether the Republican money advantage will affect the presidential race.



JUDY WOODRUFF: And with us once again, as they have been every night for the last two weeks in Tampa and in Charlotte, are Shields and Brooks. That's syndicated columnist Mark Shields and New York Times columnist David Brooks.
So, gentlemen, I promise not to talk about your -- the circles under your eyes, if you promise not to talk about the circles under my eyes.
(LAUGHTER)
JUDY WOODRUFF: So these undecided voters, David, what do you make of all that?
DAVID BROOKS: I thought they made a lot of good points.
I sometimes have little patience for undecided voters, but I thought they hit a lot of issues that are absolutely crucial, lack of agenda, who can get things done, certain betrayals.
And I guess my advice would be focus on the two things we're certain -- or three things we're certain of.
First, we know there's a fiscal cliff coming in December. Which of these two gentlemen is more likely to control the Congress to getting a deal? Because there's a real possibility they will not get a deal and we will have a recession in December. That's a real possibility.
The second thing is health care. We know that, if Romney wins, he will repeal. We know that, if Obama wins, he will not. So that is a concrete thing. You don't have to be fuzzy about that. You know.
And then, third, growth agenda, who is offering one?
And I guess my own perspective on that is the Republicans have a skewed growth agenda and the Democrats have no growth agenda. So you're picking between imperfections.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Mark, the comments they made were striking. He didn't answer how to fix the economy. There wasn't much policy there. What did you make of what they said?
MARK SHIELDS: I found it fascinating, and it's a great reminder to all of us who opine on politics that elections are about voters. They're not about candidates. They're not about Barack Obama, Mitt Romney. They're about voters.
And voters can't be pigeonholed. I mean, those are complicated, interesting people. They don't fit in to, oh, this is where my left-handed independent will break on the issues. They're going to be strong on defense, and, therefore, they're going to be anti-tax, whatever.
They were just -- I thought what they had to offer -- I thought the most interesting observation to me was the young man who said that Barack Obama is just bruised and wounded after four years. I mean, one way to look at it is that he's gray, he's seasoned, he's survived. But that's another way of looking at it.
And the woman who felt betrayed because the president made his reassurance that, on religious freedom, religious liberty, and that he wouldn't encroach, and certainly the convention celebrated, celebrated loudly and continuously, a woman's right to choose, and with no reference made...
DAVID BROOKS: Notice nobody said, well, he had Clint Eastwood. Oh, no, he had Mary J. Blige.
MARK SHIELDS: Yes. No.
DAVID BROOKS: These sort of things which we talk about a lot.
JUDY WOODRUFF: The things that we end up talking about, because...
DAVID BROOKS: Yes.
JUDY WOODRUFF: But when you hear them say, I wanted more detail, is that -- are they going to get that on the campaign trail?
DAVID BROOKS: No.
And I have sort of been a broken record on this. I don't think you have to lay out 59-point plans. But I do think there has to be a road, say on growth. What creates growth in the economy over the next two years or year? What do you believe creates growth?
Romney, I guess, believes tax cuts will create that growth. Obama, I think he believes that stimulus spending creates growth. I think he's a Keynesian.
But there's no mention of that. And he's not offering that, probably because it's politically not that popular right now. But if he does believe stimulus spending creates growth -- he has talked about his jobs bill, though, before that, to be fair.
MARK SHIELDS: Yes.
DAVID BROOKS: But I didn't hear that in the convention or in the convention speech.
So he should say, I believe in more stimulus spending.
JUDY WOODRUFF: I actually think...
MARK SHIELDS: Yes.
My dissent would be this, that this election is Bill Clinton's third term. That was -- the most interesting speech we heard in the two conventions by a factor of four was Bill Clinton's.
Bill Clinton made, I thought, the most persuasive case for growth, which was that discrimination and ignorance and poverty are a dampener, are an antidote to growth, and that, therefore, the investment in education and social services was a growth -- was it in a year or two? No.
But, I mean, that's -- that's a distinct and profound difference, I think, between the two parties.
DAVID BROOKS: A., I don't think it's a difference. Everyone is trying to reform education. And a lot of their policies are pretty similar, frankly, charter schools and merit pay and things like that.
But -- and I -- believe me, I completely agree with that, but that's a 30-year proposition. It's really important, but it's a 30-year proposition, the kids who are 5 and 6 now.
But, in the next two years, we're in a potential of a lost decade, of a Japan or a European-style lost decade. What are we going to do about that?
MARK SHIELDS: Well, I guess we're going to increase defense spending and cut taxes. I mean, that seems to be the growth agenda.
DAVID BROOKS: Right.
MARK SHIELDS: I mean, that -- which is a bizarre growth agenda.
DAVID BROOKS: Well, I have my problems with that as well.
I would -- I think we need to cut the corporate tax. I'm not convinced the income tax, if we cut that, that will make a big growth. I think we need to fix the regulatory environment. We really need to fix sequestration, what is about to happen in December. There is probably bipartisan agreement about that.
I think we need to fix immigration. There are a lot of things floating out there that we could do. And I think you could get a pretty bipartisan agenda. And you could list nine things we're going to do right away.
JUDY WOODRUFF: But is either candidate talking about that? And I want to ask you both about -- burying the lead here -- we got new jobs numbers today. The unemployment rate went down, but only 96,000 jobs were created, Mark, last month.
MARK SHIELDS: Well, and Jared Bernstein was very candid. It's a weak jobs report. It's down from July.
The irony is that there were more jobs created in July, and the percentage went up, and fewer jobs created in August, and the percentage of unemployed went down. But the reality is, it's bad news. It's bad news for the country and it's bad news for the president.
JUDY WOODRUFF: How does it change things?
DAVID BROOKS: Well, you know, it's part of 43 months of that we keep hearing, oh, we shouldn't react to one jobs report. We have had 43 of them.
And, to me, the worst part about it is, if we were scuffling along slowly, moving uphill, then you could say one thing, but 2012 is worse than 2011. We're not moving uphill. We're moving gradually downhill.
And so that is bad. And so that's why -- that's really the -- I thought the president's -- my problem with the president's speech was incrementalism, the idea that we have got these policies in place, and, incrementally, we're moving forward.
I don't think, incrementally, we're moving forward. I think, incrementally, we're -- we're either staying the same or scuffling a little downhill. And, so, to me, that's the significance of the jobs number, that not -- not only no slow progress, lack of progress.
JUDY WOODRUFF: So...
MARK SHIELDS: Yes. I think -- I think you can point to areas of progress, but the progress is certainly not as fast or intense as you would hoped.
The message really came down to one that President Reagan used, which is stay the course. I mean, that is essentially the president's message coming out of the convention in Charlotte.
JUDY WOODRUFF: And, if that's the case, then where does this campaign stand right now?
MARK SHIELDS: This campaign is a total anomaly to my experience.
By every measurement, President Obama should be 10 points behind. I mean, no president has been reelected to the White House since 1967, when the Conference Board began its confidence, consumer confidence index, with a consumer confidence figure lower than 95.
And, right now, it's at 60 -- 60 -- and the president is tied or ahead. You have got unemployment at 8.1. No president has been reelected with those numbers since Franklin Roosevelt and the Great Depression. And yet the president is tied or ahead.
I mean, it's either a great tribute to the personal support and enthusiasm and intense following that he has personally, beyond the issues, the weakness of Mitt Romney, and the Republican message, or whatever. But he is defying political gravity right now.
DAVID BROOKS: Yes, I completely agree with that.
You look not only at these numbers. You look at the wages for non-supervisory personal, sort of working-class, middle-class wages, plummeting, plummeting over the last two years. And yet he's hanging in there.
And I think it's for the reasons Mark describes. I also think we're much more locked into our party affiliations and, therefore, there's just less movement. And then I guess I think he's running a better campaign right now. And what we're seeing, the early polls out of the convention, the Democratic Convention, they seem to have gotten a bounce.
It was very hard to see one out of the Republican Convention. But the polls that concluded after the Clinton speech show, so far, maybe there will be a three-point bounce. But it's not historically big, but it's better than what the Republicans got.
JUDY WOODRUFF: But we keep hearing now the Republicans have, what, a $60 million advantage going into the rest of the campaign. Is that -- at what point does money become determinative?
MARK SHIELDS: Money becomes determinative when states become in play and you can force your opponent to defend his turf.
That's exactly what Barack Obama did in 2008 against John McCain by spending and outspending him in states like Virginia, which had not voted Democratic since 1964, North Carolina, which had not voted Democratic since 1976.
You go into states like that and start spending money, which Republicans, with limited funds then, didn't expect to defend. And now you have got President Obama. If you -- do you go into Wisconsin and spend a bundle? Do you go into Michigan, whatever, to tie up the president? I mean, that's what it does. It gives you more -- more tactical latitude.
DAVID BROOKS: I'm more skeptical that money makes a difference.
When you look at the evidence, what -- when you -- people do a big ad, all the Bain ads against Romney, it did drive his personals down, but it didn't really affect his vote. And so I do think, when you look at the door, you see effect at a presidential rate. You can drive personals down or up, but the vote has been remarkably stable.
And then think of the independents we just saw, the comments we just heard. Do we really think any of those people are going to be affected by an ad? I'm a little dubious about that. There's a lot of information they're processing, and ads I think go through an extremely thick filter in those kind of voters' minds.
JUDY WOODRUFF: So, in less than a minute, to both of you, what does it take to shake this race up? Or do we just look at this steady slogging ahead, Mark?
MARK SHIELDS: No. I mean, we have several interactions. We have got four debates.
JUDY WOODRUFF: Three presidential.
MARK SHIELDS: One vice presidential debates, and three presidential, where they're going to stand on the same stage. It's not going to be a matter of money or competing advertising terms.
And people -- I think voters...
JUDY WOODRUFF: Our own Jim Lehrer is going to moderating the first one.
MARK SHIELDS: Our own Jim Lehrer has the first one, which is probably the most important one, because you're going to -- that's when we're all personnel directors or human services chiefs.
And we kind of look at them. And are these the qualities we're looking for?
DAVID BROOKS: Yes.
And I guess I would say that they're really good at campaigning against each other. They're both pretty good at negativity. So, either one of them will hit a knockout blow, or else somebody will actually come up with something positive. And it will be one of those two things. I would love to see one of the candidates come out with something positive. I really don't expect to see that.
MARK SHIELDS: The first one that shows a flash of humor will surge, and especially -- and self-deprecating humor. And I'm not sure that that's a natural...
JUDY WOODRUFF: I'm writing that down right now, first one to show...
MARK SHIELDS: There's at least...
DAVID BROOKS: I'm humble. I'm humble, just like Abraham Lincoln.
(LAUGHTER)
MARK SHIELDS: Yes. That's it.
JUDY WOODRUFF: All right, next time I see you both, you're going to get some rest between now and then.
MARK SHIELDS: Ooh.
DAVID BROOKS: Guaranteed.
MARK SHIELDS: That hurt.
JUDY WOODRUFF: You look good, but I know you want some rest.
(LAUGHTER)
JUDY WOODRUFF: Mark Shields, David Brooks, thank you.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Obama picked to win in 2012 (Aug31/11)


August 31, 2011, 4:38 PM

Despite Keys, Obama Is No Lock

Allan J. Lichtman, a presidential historian at American University, has issued a prediction that, given an economy still teetering on the brink of recession and President Obama’s 40 percent approval ratings, looks awfully bold.
“Even if I am being conservative, I don’t see how Obama can lose,” Mr. Lichtman told Paul Bedard of U.S. News & World Report.
Mr. Lichtman’s prediction is based on his 1984 book “The Keys to the White House”. The book cites 13 factors that can work for or against the party of the incumbent president. If at least eight of the 13 keys are scored in favor of the incumbent, he will win the election, Mr. Lichtman says; if he gets seven or fewer, he will not.
The book claims to have called the winner of the popular vote correctly in each election since 1860. (It would not have gotten the winner of the Electoral College right in 1876, 1888 or 2000, when the popular and electoral vote split.) That’s 38 elections in a row! Superficially quite impressive.
But ‘superficial’ is the crucial term here. There are several problems with this model, and its results should be taken with a grain of salt.
First has to do with the nature of the keys themselves, several of which are quite subjective.
1. Party mandate: After the midterm elections, the incumbent party holds more seats in the House of Representatives than it did after the previous midterm elections.
2. Contest: There is no serious contest for the incumbent party nomination.
3. Incumbency: The incumbent party’s candidate is the sitting president.
4. Third Party: There is no significant third party challenge.
5. Short-term economy: The economy is not in recession during the election campaign.
6. Long-term economy: Real per capita economic growth during the term equals or exceeds mean growth during the previous two terms.
7. Policy change: The incumbent administration effects major changes in national policy.
8. Social unrest: There is no sustained social unrest during the term.
9. Scandal: The incumbent administration is untainted by major scandal.
10. Foreign/military failure: The incumbent administration suffers no major failure in foreign or military affairs.
11. Foreign/military success: The incumbent administration achieves a major success in foreign or military affairs.
12. Incumbent charisma: The incumbent party’s candidate is charismatic or a national hero.
13. Challenger charisma: The challenging party’s candidate is not charismatic or a national hero.
This is most obvious in the case of the final two variables, which have to do with the charisma of the incumbent candidate and an opponent. I’m not of the view that there’s no such thing as “candidate quality,” or that charisma doesn’t matter. But it’s awfully easy to describe someone as charismatic when he or she is ahead in the polls — or when you have the advantage of hindsight and know who won an election.
Mr. Lichtman, for instance, scored Mr. Obama as charismatic in 2008, but not John McCain (even though Mr. McCain, with his service in the Navy, might have met Mr. Lichtman’s description of a “national hero”). However, Mr. Lichtman does not score Mr. Obama that way now.
At the same time, he scores some other debatable keys in favor of Mr. Obama. For instance, he gives him credit for having effected “major changes in national policy” because of the health care bill and stimulus package. Both those initiatives, especially the health care bill, are rather unpopular. On what premise will they increase his re-election chances?
Likewise, he does not call the war in Afghanistan a foreign policy failure, even though a majority of Americans think the war has gone badly and we should no longer be involved there. I’m not saying that Mr. Lichtman scored the issue wrongly — one can note that the United States does seem to have weakened Al Qaeda, or argue that any failure would be on President George W. Bush and not Mr. Obama. But it’s a debatable case.
The heart of the problem is something a little different, however: the formula is not actually all that accurate. Although it may have gotten the winners right, it does not do particularly well at accounting for their margin of victory.
Megan McArdle, a senior editor for The Atlantic, gets at this point by trying to apply the formula to Herbert Hoover, who lost to Franklin D. Roosevelt by 18 percentage points in 1932. She notes that between five and seven keys could easily be scored in favor of Hoover (Mr. Lichtman went with five) — short of the eight that Mr. Lichtman says are needed for re-election, but close enough that you wouldn’t have expected Hoover to lose in a landslide.
We can generalize this point by looking at the number of keys that each incumbent party candidate had and compare it to the margin of victory, or defeat:
As you can see, there is quite a bit of variance. For instance, James A. Garfield (in 1880), Calvin Coolidge (in 1924), Richard Nixon (in 1972) and George W. Bush (in 2004) were all scored as having nine keys in favor of them. All four won their elections. But Coolidge and Nixon won by 23 and 25 percentage points, respectively — while Garfield won the popular vote by less than 2,000 votes! Mr. Bush’s re-election in 2004, of course, was also quite close.
In fact, the 95 percent confidence interval on a projection using Mr. Lichtman’s formula is about plus or minus 16 points, which is certainly not especially precise. (Four elections in fact fall outside of the 95 percent confidence interval: 1912, 1920, 1924 and 1972.)
Looking at 1972 again, for instance, Mr. Lichtman’s formula would have predicted a Nixon victory by about 7 percentage points — when in fact, Nixon won by 23, a 17-point difference. Had George McGovern won the election by 10 points, the formula would have been just as accurate!
Or look at 1960: Nixon was scored as having just four keys in his favor, tied for the lowest score ever — but lost the popular vote by just one-tenth of a percentage point to John F. Kennedy. The formula was very, very close to being very, very wrong on this and other occasions.
Assuming that the errors in the formula are normally distributed, we can also use these historic results to translate the number of keys that an incumbent has into his probability of winning another term. For example, an incumbent who has nine keys scored in his favor — as Mr. Obama has now — has about a 79 percent chance of winning re-election, given the formula’s margin of error.
I’m sure the White House would be thrilled with a 79 percent chance of winning another term. But this hints at a another, more fundamental issue. As you can see from the table, there are lots of cases in which an incumbent’s re-election is an open question: one having eight keys scored in his favor, for example, should win about 65 percent of the time over the long run — but not 100 percent of the time. One having five keys scored in his favor, as Mr. Hoover did, should usually lose — but will pull out the victory about 18 percent of the time.
What are the odds of all these close calls just having happened to turn out right? Very low. Given the margin of error inherent in the formula, the chance of it having called the winner of the popular vote correctly in all 38 elections is only about 0.03 percent, or about 1 chance in 3,300.
In other words, given that the formula has done quite badly in predicting the margin of victory on several occasions (1932, 1960, 1972, etc.) it has been extremely lucky not to have gotten the winner wrong on at least one occasion. Over the long run, the formula should get about 20 percent of elections wrong, which would be about seven or eight misses out of a sample of 38.
Or … maybe it’s something other than luck. Although none of Mr. Lichtman’s keys are intrinsically ridiculous (for example, “which candidate had more ‘n’s in their name”), one can conceivably think of any number of other areas that might have been included in the formula but which are not — looking at how messy the primaries were for the opposition party, for example, or the inflation rate, or the ideological positioning of the candidates. (I mention these particular ones because there is some empirical evidence that they do matter.)
If there are, say, 25 keys that could defensibly be included in the model, and you can pick any set of 13 of them, that is a total of 5,200,300 possible combinations. It’s not hard to get a perfect score when you have that large a menu to pick from! Some of those combinations are going to do better than others just by chance alone.
In addition, as I mentioned, at least a couple of variables can credibly be scored in either direction for each election. That gives Mr. Lichtman even more flexibility. It’s less that he has discovered the right set of keys than that he’s a locksmith and can keep minting new keys until he happens to open all 38 doors.
By the way — many of these concerns also apply to models that use solely objective data, like economic variables. These models tell you something, but they are not nearly as accurate as claimed when held up to scrutiny. While you can’t manipulate economic variables — you can’t say that G.D.P. growth was 5 percent when the government said it was 2 percent, at least if anyone is paying attention — you can choose from among dozens of economic variables until you happen to find the ones that pick the lock.
These types of problems, which are technically known as overfitting and data dredging, are among the most important things you ought to learn about in a well-taught econometrics class — but many published economists and political scientists seem to ignore them when it comes to elections forecasting.
In short, be suspicious of results that seem too good to be true. I’m probably in the minority here, but if two interns applied to FiveThirtyEight, and one of them claimed to have a formula that predicted 33 of the last 38 elections correctly, and the other one said they had gotten all 38 right, I’d hire the first one without giving it a second thought — it’s far more likely that she understood the limitations of empirical and statistical analysis.
As for Mr. Obama, I’d note that only two of Mr. Lichtman’s 13 keys pertain to the economy, or 15 percent. Even our Republican readers, I think, would be ready to concede him another four years if the economy accounted for only 15 percent of voters’ decision. Mr. Lichtman’s keys do remind us that there are a number of noneconomic areas — for instance, the killing of Osama bin Laden, or the general avoidance of scandal — in which Mr. Obama has performed well.
But chances are that the economy is going to be much more important than that: my research suggests that it accounts for about half of a voter’s decision. If the economic factors are bad for Mr. Obama, and noneconomic factors are basically good for him, then that’s why the election figures to be on a razor’s edge.